MENUMENU
  • Services
    • Services
      • Search Engine Optimization
      • Local SEO
      • Generative Engine Optimization
      • Digital PR
      • Content Marketing
      • Email Marketing Services
      • Lifecycle Marketing
      • Paid Media Advertising
      • Social Media Marketing
      • Creative Design Services
      • Conversion Rate Optimization
      • Website Design & Development
      • Amazon Marketing Services
      • Franchise Marketing
      • Franchise Development
      • National to Local Marketing
      • Reporting and Data Analytics
      • Digital Marketing Strategy
  • Who We Serve
    • Who We Serve
      • Franchise Marketing
      • B2B Marketing
      • Lead Generation
      • Ecommerce
      • We Build Custom Strategies
      • View Sample Industries
  • About Us
    • About Ignite Visibility
      • Our Story
      • Our Values
      • Our Team
      • Clients
      • Diversity & Inclusion
      • Our Blog
      • Marketing Resources
      • Franchise Marketing Resources
      • Careers
      • Hiring Notice
  • Case Studies
  • Awards
  • Contact
  • 619.752.1955
Home / Search Engine Optimization / Why Looking at Total SEO Traffic Is Misleading

Why Looking at Total SEO Traffic Is Misleading

October 9, 2015 By John Lincoln

Website traffic is a complex thing. I have spent the last decade analyzing it and I can tell you with certainty that most people don’t understand important subtleties in their online traffic. In this post, I want to talk about some of those. Let’s start out with a couple non-SEO related items and then we will jump into SEO specifically.

Why Looking at Your Total SEO Traffic is Just Dead Wrong

 

Referring Site Spam

First, referring site spam is way up in Google Analytics. There is a good chance that 10% to 30% of the traffic you are getting in your referring site report (depending on the size of your site and the industry) is total junk. This is also true for SEO traffic, but not nearly on the same scale. There is certainly false query data in a lot of the reports I have seen.

Tracking Errors

Tracking errors are much more prevalent than you think. I would say that 50% of the websites I see have some sort of tracking error issue that influences reporting. For example:

  • They don’t realize the tracking code is on another site or subdomain, inflating their data
  • Tracking code is missing on pages
  • They set up some type of event tracking that is causing inflated visits
  • They migrated a website the previous year and had a major abnormality because of it
  • The list goes on.

It is very important to understand the big picture; otherwise you could be over or under reporting.

Understanding SEO Traffic Specifically and Subtle Important Points

Now, when it comes to SEO traffic there are some really important things that you need to understand. Here are a few.

New Visitors vs Returning

When it comes to subscription based websites (and sites with an ongoing customer base), generally, if you are doing a good job and growing your business your returning visitors from organic search will increase. These people search the company name and end up coming back to the site. That is why it is good to also look at new visitors that organic search is attracting and evaluate that year over year. Generally, pages that have been recently updated will attract more new visitors. I will explain more in a moment.

Websites have Different Segments and Pages

Perhaps the most important misconception that undermines true understanding of an online business is a lack of general knowledge regarding segments of the website. For example, do you think that organic traffic to member login page should be part of your SEO report? That page deals with your returning visitors… How about your forum or knowledge base? Or your customer support page? If your SEO team has not done any work on certain sections, or if those sections are not related to new customer acquisition, they should not be responsible for a decline or rise in traffic to those sections. They should be omitted.

Often we will see that companies try to look at overall traffic. But if you have a section of your website that is not meant to be ranked and has not been worked on that just doesn’t make sense. If that section is down 30%, that can kill your entire report and result in unjustified scrutiny. When in fact, your numbers for the information and service pages you have worked on are up. As a final example, consider last year you no indexed 1,000 pages because you were afraid of a Panda penalty, but those pages did 15,000 a month in traffic, you need to note that in reporting.

Maintaining Old Pages

Now, say that you hired me as an SEO consultant. We started working together about 2 years ago and have had a lot of success. In the first year you hired me, we built out 100 location pages and had a traffic increase of 140% and the same for revenue. Now, it is 2 years later and traffic is down to the location pages. Why would that happen? Well, let me explain. When you launch the new pages they get indexed by Google. Google ranks them highly and tests them, and then they settle into their normal position. Overtime, if those pages are not updated with fresh content, linked to in blog posts, generating social shares, generating social links, lacking a content updating widget, etc., then traffic to them will decline and they will eventually fade into the night. Every page you create must be maintained. Think of it like this. Say you plant 1,000 orange trees. You get a big harvest. But you don’t water them for the next two years. Those trees are not going to produce as well without some love.

Adding new Pages and Working on Specific Sections

If you are adding new quality content to your website on a continual basis, you will increase your traffic. There is no question about it. Also, if you update and improve pages you will increase the traffic to those pages. When it comes to SEO reporting, the pages that company is working on are the most important and really the only ones they can account for. Now, if they are a good SEO company they may put a template in place that has fresh content generating capabilities. I will talk about that more in a future post.

Competitive Keywords

Websites generally have their list of top terms. If you fall off for a very highly trafficked term, your traffic is going to go down. Say you renew with your SEO company and when you do you remove all the external linking. Your competitor on the other hand is doing everything they can to get links to the page that ranks for their top term. They are putting it in high-quality niche directories, creating news surrounding the service so that people are linking to it and doing significant outreach, in the right way. You are probably going to fall off for that term and lose that traffic. While on the other hand, if when you renewed you signed up for local listings your location pages are going to rank higher. The point being, you only get results on the portion of your website that you work on.

Summing it Up

At the end of the day, website traffic is a complex thing. Pages have different purposes, traffic comes from different channels, locations and devices and spam and tracking errors are ever present. Understanding your analytics and how that related to SEO is near impossible for someone new to the space. Make sure you work with someone you trust and who really knows their stuff, otherwise, you could be operating off of completely false pretenses and make poor business decisions as a result. Learn more about this topic in SEO reporting the right way, 19 reports your boss wants to see.

Related Posts

  • Hummingbird Update SEO Video

    The Hummingbird Update Changed SEO - In this video, John Lincoln, President of SEO and…

  • International SEO Training Video

    Ready to learn international SEO? Get ready, there is a lot to know. In this…

  • Voice Search SEO, How Voice Search is Changing SEO

    Voice search SEO is here! You can now search by talking on smart phones and…

About John Lincoln

John Lincoln (MBA) is the CEO of Ignite Visibility, a top performance marketing agency backed by Mountaingate Capital. A digital marketing strategist and keynote speaker, Lincoln has managed over 1,000 marketing programs for brands like DoorDash, HBO, Tony Robbins, and Experian. Under his leadership, Ignite Visibility has been named a leading digital marketing agency in the U.S. and made the Inc. 5,000 list six times. Lincoln also spearheaded the development of CertaintyTech, a cutting-edge media mix modelling and forecasting platform. An award-winning marketer, Lincoln has authored three books, including Advolution (2022), and produced films such as SEO: The Movie. Recognized as a Top Business Leader, he has been featured in Forbes and The New York Times and spoken at global events like Web Summit and SMX. Lincoln's mission is to empower businesses through innovative digital strategies while reinvesting in clients, employees, and the community.

About Ignite

Ignite Visibility is a premier full-service digital marketing agency. We were founded in San Diego, CA but are now a 100% remote-first company with Igniters and clients around the globe.

Ignite Visibility is one of the highest awarded digital marketing agencies in the industry, works with some of the biggest brands in the world and is a 6x Inc. 5000 company.

noun-trading

Our Services

Ignite Visibility offers Award-Winning Services including comprehensive full-funnel digital marketing strategies. Learn more about our most popular service offerings below:

  • SEO Search Engine Optimization
  • PPC Pay Per Click
  • Email Marketing
  • Social Media
  • Creative
  • View All Services

Contact Us. Let’s Chat!

  • This field is hidden when viewing the form

Marketing Guides

SEO In 2020: How To Prepare For Major Disruption

"SEO: The Movie" - Have You Seen Our Film? Watch Now

"Social Media Marketing: The Movie" - Have You Seen Our Film? Watch Now

Amazon Seller Central vs Vendor Central

Listen To The Podcast Featuring The Best Minds In Marketing

John Lincoln Interviews Global Director of Digital Marketing & Strategy at Qualcomm, Jessica Jensen

Check Out 227 Free Online Marketing Classes

The 2020 Guide To Dominating SEO With Advanced Schema

Learn More About Our Digital Marketing Agency

Learn More About Our SEO Services

Learn More About Our Paid Media Services

SELECT CATEGORY

Become A Contributor

Interested in writing for Ignite Visibility?

APPLY NOW

noun-chat

Let's Chat

Ready to grow your online visibility and sales?

Request Your Free Proposal

Work With Us

NEWSLETTER // SIGN UP NOW










noun-strategy

Free Marketing Resources

  • Digital Marketing Resources
  • Marketing Strategy Videos
  • Weekly Marketing News Recaps
noun-strategy

Most Popular Blogs

  • How Long Does SEO Take?
  • Multi-Location SEO: Top Strategies
  • Google AI Overviews: Everything You Need to Know
  • Technical SEO 101
  • 18 Google Ad Extensions You Should Use
  • Complete Guide to Google Responsive Display Ads
  • Capitalizing on Local Service Ads
  • How SEO and PPC Work Together
  • Community Management Best Practices
  • B2B Social Media Marketing Guide
  • VIEW ALL BLOGS
noun-letter

Join Our Newsletter

CONNECT WITH US

  • facebook
  • twitter
  • instagram
  • youtube
  • linkedin

Services

  • Search Engine Optimization
  • Generative Engine Optimization
  • Pay Per Click Management
  • Social Media Marketing
  • Email Marketing
  • Conversion Rate Optimization
  • Website Design & Development
  • Creative Design
  • Content Marketing
  • Digital PR
  • Franchise Marketing
  • Digital Marketing Agency Services

About

  • Our Team
  • Our Values
  • Clients
  • Industry
  • Reviews
  • Careers
  • Marketing Resources
  • Privacy Policy & Service Terms
  • Advertising Disclosures
  • Sitemap

Contact

4370 La Jolla Village Drive
Suite 320
San Diego, California 92122

619.752.1955

Join The Newsletter

Sign up for our newsletter to get the latest from Ignite Visibility.











google parther logo

©2025 Ignite Visibility. All Rights Reserved. Privacy Policy and Terms of Service